Follow by Email

Saturday, April 9, 2016

Fearful Drivers are the Greatest Ignored Danger on the Road
Good article thanks to Seth Parks and Links provided:

March, 2016  Drivers afraid to be behind the wheel are a misunderstood threat to road safety. Fearful driving often leads to excessive caution masquerading as politeness. Resulting behaviors may appear benign, when in fact they can be grave.
For example, arriving first at a four-way stop but waving others through creates confusion for other road users. Cynthia Lewellen, an Oregon cyclist, was hit by a motorist last year after a well-intentioned driver waved Juan Carlos Garcia through an intersection in advance of the appropriate right-first sequence. The approbative driver may not have been acting out of the timidity of fear, but the point is in the danger of this driver’s behavior. Garcia’s F-250 struck Lewellen fracturing her pelvis, shoulder, ribs, sacrum, and tailbone.
Ill advised signaling, poor lane choice, and misplaced courtesy put other motorists and pedestrians at risk. Psychologists have long understood the challenge posed by a fear of driving, which at the extreme can be exhibited as panic attacks and freezing. Fearful drivers also demonstrate less catastrophic symptoms, such as confusion and disorientation. The American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) codifies driving disorders; specifically, Diagnostic Code 300.29, Specific Phobia, Driving Type. Mental health specialists have gone further by defining a variety of driving related phobias – vehophobiaamaxophobiahamaxophobia,ochophobiadystychiphobia, and motorphobia.
As with most psychological conditions, people experience driving-related phobias on a spectrum. The most egregiously afflicted rarely take to the road, whereas those with less severe phobic traits drive daily. Some fearful drivers seek help and there are effective therapies. Multiple self-help bookshave been published on the topic. The most significant danger to road safety is from the millions of daily drivers on the phobic spectrum. These people either do not recognize their condition or do not believe their anxiety is a danger to others.
A variety of factors can contribute to a fear of driving. A traumatizing incident can be a trigger, as can growing up in an auto-free environment. Here is how one fearful driver expressed her experience.
I just cannot handle how much power I have to literally kill someone at a moment’s notice when I’m in the car. Not because I’m some sort of Dexter-style psychopath … My body is tense. My brain is confused. I don’t trust myself that I’m good at this. I can convince myself into doing it, but it doesn’t ever seem like it could be second nature like it is for some people,” said Kate Dries, Managing Editor at Gawker Media, in 2013.
The remedy is not entirely clear, but a measure of tolerance, patience, and distance among other drivers would be healthy (I’m pointing a finger at myself here).
But what are the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and Insurance Institute for highway Safety (IIHS) doing about fearful driving?
Fearful driving is not acknowledged as a causal factor in traffic accidents. In 2008, the NHTSA delivered the National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey to Congress. The exhaustive three-year study sampled 5,471 light vehicles crashes nationwide, with a focus on the factors related to pre-crash events. More than 600 data points were collected for each crash capturing driver, vehicle, roadway, and environmental conditions. The report attributed 33 percent of driver-related critical reasons for accidents to decision errors. A decision error is a catch-all category including false assumptions of others’ actions, illegal maneuvers, misjudgment of gap and speed, etc. Some of these decision errors are likely the result of fearful, timid, anxious driving. However, there is no mention of fear or phobia within the report’s 47 pages. Panic is discussed as a pre-crash performance attribute, but not as a causal factor.
The Auto Insurance Center, an independent news and information source for consumers, conducted a study using NHTSA data. It found that between 2009 and 2013 the second most common accident inducing behavior on American roads was failing to yield the right-of-way. They make no mention of fear, but other top-ten causes included failure to keep in proper lane, over correction, and improper turns. All drivers are capable of these mistakes, but fearful driving exacerbates poor decision making and contributes to dangerous behaviors. The mainstream mental health community has identified the danger of fearful driving and developed therapies. The road safety establishment has yet to acknowledge the danger.
Traveling by car has become dramatically safer. Over the last five decades, proper lighting, collapsible steering wheels, anti-lock brakes, and other advances have helped steadily reduce deaths per million miles traveled. Additional improvements such as lane-departure warning and automated braking systems will continue to reduce the threat drivers pose. And other high-profile dangers remain, such as in-car distraction, fatigue, and substance abuse. However, the presence of other legitimate risk factors along with ever-improving vehicle safety do not mean the risk of fearful driving should be dismissed. The driving environment is becoming more dense and complex, elevating anxiety among those already fearful when taking the wheel. The road safety establishment needs to study and address fearful driving as a legitimate factor in traffic safety.
The 2008 NHTSA study determined that 94 percent of accidents are caused by drivers. Other studies have reached similar conclusions – people cause car accidents. Fearful drivers do not respond well amid confident, decisive drivers and are part of the road safety equation. They are the greatest ignored danger on the road today.

No comments:

Post a Comment